Halloween and murder mysteries are a match made in spooky heaven! If you're hosting a Halloween murder mystery party, choosing the right costume is half the fun. Here are some costume ideas tailored to each murder mystery theme to help your guests look the part and stay in character.
Guests are not limited to specific costumes for any of the themes, so there is room for flexibility if your guests want to dress up however they want. These suggestions are just a jumping off point!
Halloween Party Theme
For a classic Halloween murder mystery, embrace the traditional spooky aesthetic. Guests can dress as iconic Halloween characters like vampires, ghosts, witches, or mad scientists. Think Victorian-era vampires with capes and fangs, or classic white sheet ghosts with a modern twist. Other great options include ghouls, fortune tellers, and creepy carnival performers. The key is to keep costumes mysterious and slightly sinister while maintaining that timeless Halloween vibe.
In this game, play as guests at a huge Halloween house party-- this means that you can dress up however you'd like. If you want to dress up as Mr. Clean or do a lampshade/moth couples costume, that works great. The sky is truly the limit and this is the most flexible Halloween theme!!
Find the game here!
Monster Mayhem Theme
This theme calls for classic movie monsters and creature costumes. Guests should consider dressing as Frankenstein's monster, the Mummy, werewolves, or The Creature from the Black Lagoon. You can also include modern monster interpretations like creepy aliens, giant insects, or twisted versions of fairy tale characters. Encourage bold makeup and prosthetics to really bring these monsters to life. The more dramatic and theatrical, the better!
In this game, there are specific monsters for the characters which will vary depending on your number/gender of players. We encourage guests to dress up as their character (i.e. Astrid the Werewolf) but it is not necessary for the game to work.
Find the game here!
Haunted House Theme
For a haunted house mystery, costumes should evoke a sense of ghostly elegance mixed with dread. Think Victorian spirits in tattered gowns, ghostly mansion staff members in old-fashioned uniforms, cursed residents in period clothing, clowns, or spectral versions of 1920s socialites. Guests can also dress as paranormal investigators, spiritualists, or house staff from different eras. Pale makeup, ethereal fabrics, and vintage clothing work wonderfully for this atmospheric theme.
This theme takes place in a popular Haunted House where guests will play as scare actors, visitors, and other people who are curious about the attraction.
Find the game here!
Witch Coven Theme
A witch coven theme offers endless creative possibilities. Guests can dress as traditional witches with pointy hats and broomsticks, modern witches in dark stylish clothing, potion masters, or members of a magical cult. Consider allowing variations like hedge witches, sea witches, forest witches, or cosmic witches. Encourage mystical accessories like tarot cards, crystal necklaces, spell books, and cauldrons. Dark colors, flowing fabrics, and magical imagery set the perfect tone.
In this game, there is a gathering of witches as they work to determine the coven's next leader. Dress up as whatever type of witch you like and be creative!
Find the game here!
Zombie Apocalypse Theme
For a zombie apocalypse murder mystery, the costume options are delightfully grotesque. While the players in the game are apocalypse survivors, feel free to dress up as a gory zombie with fun makeup. Other ideas include zombie hunters, apocalypse survivors in tattered tactical gear, or mutant creatures. Torn clothing and an overall "undead" appearance are essential for this thrilling theme.
Find the game here!
No matter which murder mystery theme you choose, the most important thing is that your guests have fun embodying their characters. These costume ideas will help set the perfect atmosphere for an unforgettable Halloween murder mystery experience!
Halloween is coming up and it's a great time to start planning a super fun party to remember. But if you're more of a last minute planner, we send all games within 24 hours of purchase and set up can be as minimal as printing (or you can view documents on your phone if you do not want to print!). All our games can also be played virtually if your friends and family are scattered around.