Guilty games
Slaying at the Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery Party Game - digital files delivered via email
Couldn't load pickup availability
🧙Uncover the Secrets of Salem in This Witch Trials-Themed Murder Mystery Game (5–15 Players) 🔥
Step back in time to 1692 with this Salem Witch Trials-themed interactive murder mystery game! Perfect for 5 to 15 players, this thrilling game invites your guests to take on dramatic roles in a town haunted by secrets, suspicion… and murder.
💌 How It Works:
This is a digital download, so no physical product will be shipped. You’ll receive your complete game kit via email within 24 hours of purchase. Files will be sent to the email associated with your Etsy account—if you'd like it sent elsewhere, just leave a note at checkout.
🖨️ Heads-Up!
There’s a lot to print—character sheets, clue cards, and more—so make sure you have access to a printer (or printing service) before purchasing.
🎉 Perfect For:
-
Halloween parties
-
Themed birthdays
-
History buffs
-
Game nights with a spooky twist
Ready to discover who’s truly bewitched… and who’s just hiding a deadly secret?
INTRODUCTION TO SALEM WITCH TRIALS MURDER MYSTERY PARTY THEME:
Salem, Massachusetts, is home to chaos. After accusations of witchcraft began to run rampant across town, neighbor turned against neighbor, brother against sister, father against daughter. No one was safe, and everyone had the chance to become the Salem witch hunts next victim. However, when Anna Belle, a young girl living in Salem, began accusing countless people, numbering well over a dozen, she became both loved and feared. Her accusations alone led to the deaths of 13 men, women, and children- and she was next. Anna was found dead in Salem’s courtroom. She was strangled to death, and left sitting in the testimony stand. Found by her body was a pearl necklace which had been placed around her neck, a message written in red paint on the courtroom wall reading “you will pay”, a rope, and two large cement blocks. Anna was killed in the middle of the night, and her body was found the next morning, on hanging day. Hanging day was when the guilty were supposed to face their punishments, but it was postponed due to Anna’s murder. Someone killed Anna, and nobody knows who did it, not even the killer themself. It could be any of you, and it is up to you to figure out who had the motive, means, and opportunity to murder Anna Belle. Good luck.
What is included in your murder mystery party game:
- Host guide
- Introduction
- Character Packets
- Autopsy Report
- Note Sheets
- Name Tags
- Confession voting forms
- Confession
- Extras
This isn't your typical read-along game—Slaying at the Salem Witch Trials is a completely unscripted murder mystery, meaning your guests must think like true detectives, ask their own questions, and use their intuition to uncover the killer. No scripts, no spoilers—just immersive roleplay, suspense, and clever deduction in a chilling 1692 Salem setting.
🧾 What's Included & How It Works:
Once your payment is processed, you’ll receive all game materials via email—no waiting! Just download, print, and you're ready to host your mystery party almost immediately. Every guest receives unique character details and secrets that drive the game forward, ensuring an unforgettable experience from start to finish.
🖨️ Please Note:
A printer is required, and there's a significant amount to print, including character booklets, clues, and game instructions. This ensures a rich, detailed experience for all participants. The amount of printing will vary depending on the number of players.
If you have any questions, feel free to reach out—we’re here to help you create an unforgettable night of mystery, mayhem, and magic.
Share





- Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
- Opens in a new window.