Skip to product information
1 of 6

Guilty games

Slaying at the Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery Party Game - digital files delivered via email

Slaying at the Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery Party Game - digital files delivered via email
Regular price $15.00 USD
Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Number of Players
View full details

Game difficulty

Intermediate-Difficult

Costume suggestions

Colonial witch costumes for the win! Get dressed in your best historical look with a witchy twist.

Time to play

1.5-2.5 hours

Game play

Detective style freeform game where the host can play along

Plot

Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery Introduction To The Theme

Salem, Massachusetts, is home to chaos. After accusations of witchcraft began to run rampant across town, neighbor turned against neighbor, brother against sister, father against daughter. No one was safe, and everyone had the chance to become the Salem witch hunt’s next victim. 

However, when Anna Belle, a young girl living in Salem, began accusing countless people, numbering well over a dozen, she became both loved and feared. Her accusations alone led to the deaths of 13 men, women, and children- and she was next. 

Anna was found dead in Salem’s courtroom. She was strangled to death, and left sitting in the testimony stand. Found by her body was a pearl necklace which had been placed around her neck, a message written in red paint on the courtroom wall reading “you will pay”, a rope, and two large cement blocks. 

Anna was killed in the middle of the night, and her body was found the next morning, on hanging day. Hanging day was when the guilty were supposed to face their punishments, but it was postponed due to Anna’s murder.

Someone killed Anna, and nobody knows who did it, not even the killer themselves. It could be any of you, and it is up to you to figure out who had the motive, means, and opportunity to murder Anna Belle. Good luck.

Sample Characters (Actual Characters Will Vary Based on Number/Gender of Players)

Bridget Bishop was the first woman to be accused of witchcraft in Salem. She owned a local tavern which was an attraction both to locals and travelers, and after the recent death of her husband, was very lonely. She was married three times, and all of her husbands had tragically died. She mourned each of them, although some people found her to be suspicious because of it.

Sarah Good was accused of witchcraft, and one of the first three to be accused. Two young townspeople accused her, one of whom was Andrew Williams. Sarah lived a hard life, often being forced to beg for food or shelter, and at the time of her conviction, she was pregnant. Sarah was innocent, and while she tried to make her innocence known, it seemed like no one was listening.

Martha Carrier served as a servant to Salem’s most prestigious family. They paid her well, and she lived with them, providing her with a very nice, safe life. However, after one of the family’s children choked to death under her watch, Martha was accused of witchcraft. She had yet to be tried, but the final verdict would likely not be in her favor. 

Henry Griggs is Salem’s one and only resident doctor, and he has specialized in determining which of Salem’s residents have been possessed, and thus need to be accused of witchcraft. He does not treat convicted witches, but rather sentences them to death, and has contributed to many hangings.

Andrew Williams was one of the initial accusers in the Salem Witch trials, and he became afflicted. He began having fits, and Dr. Griggs proclaimed that he was a victim of witchcraft. Andrew contributed to the deaths of twenty women through his accusations, yet to him, it was all a game.

Elizabeth Proctor, alongside her husband, was convicted of witchcraft, and her husband was hung. Elizabeth was sentenced to death, yet allowed to live because she was pregnant. After the Proctor’s servant was accused of witchcraft, Elizabeth made the decision to defend her, which led to her own arrest and trial.

What's in the Digital/Printable Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery Kit

Everything you need to host an unforgettable murder mystery party

Host Guide

Host Guide

Complete instructions for hosting the perfect salem witch trials mystery

Introduction

Introduction

Set the scene with our engaging story introduction

Character Packets

Character Packets

Detailed character backgrounds and secrets for each guest

Name Tags

Name Tags

Printable name tags for all characters

Voting Forms

Voting Forms

Let guests cast their votes for the culprit

Confession

Confession

The dramatic reveal of the murderer's confession

Autopsy Report

Autopsy Report

Forensic details to help solve the mystery

Extras

Extras

Bonus materials including invitations and decorations

Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery FAQs

Can the Host Play Along in the Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery Game?

Yes, the host can play along! We include a clear host guide that explains how to host and play without spoiling the fun!

What if my number of players changes?

Send us an email! We can send you adjusted files ASAP. We have specific number of players so everyone is important--and are happy to send adjusted games.

How long does it take to play the Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery?

It takes about 1.5 to 2.5 hours to play, but the game is very easily adjusted!

Is the murder mystery scripted?

No, our mysteries are not scripted. They are freeform, detective-style games where all guests get to interactive in a more traditional party setting!

What props should I use for the Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery?

Set the scene for 1693! Witchy brews and courthouse decor will set the scene for a Salem Witch Trials themed party!

What Age Range is the Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery Good for?

The salem witch trials murder mystery game is great for older teens and adults! The game is challenging but contains no explicit content, though it does have historically accurate themes.

Can I play the Salem Witch Trials Murder Mystery Game Virtually?

Yes! Any of our games can be played virtually-- just add an order note or purchase the virtual mystery game, salem witch trials variant!