How To Plan A Murder Mystery Party: A Guide For First Timers

How To Plan A Murder Mystery Party: A Guide For First Timers

How To Plan A Murder Mystery Party: A Guide For First Timers

Murder mystery party games are the ultimate blend of suspense, laughter, and creativity. Whether you’re planning one for tweens, teens, or the whole family, the key is in the details. If this is your first time hosting, don’t worry—we’ll walk you through every step to ensure your night is unforgettable.

Step 1: Choose Your Murder Mystery Party Theme

Your theme sets the tone for the entire event. Think about the age group, setting, and level of spookiness you want. Some popular options from Guilty Games Murder Mysteries include:

When in doubt, pick a theme that excites your guests and fits your party space.

Step 2: Assign Characters Beforehand

Every murder mystery party game comes with unique characters and backstories. Assign them a few days before the party so your guests can prepare their costumes and get into character. Though if you don't get around to it, that's okay; your mystery will still be fun! Send each player their character sheet privately so no secrets get spoiled!

💡 Pro Tip: Make a graphic or chart to help you keep track of who’s playing which role—especially if you have a large guest list.

Step 3: Decorate to Match the Theme

The right atmosphere makes the game immersive. You don’t have to spend a fortune—use themed tablecloths, lighting, music, and props to bring the world to life. For example:

Slumber Party → Pajamas, popcorn, stuffed animals

Tea Party → Teacups, floral arrangements, fancy hats

Witch Coven → Candles, potion bottles, spell books

We love using Pinterest for Inspo!

Step 4: Set the Scene for the Murder

Kick off the night with a dramatic introduction from the host (that’s you!). Read the opening scenario to the group, explain the rules, and let the players mingle to gather clues.

Make sure everyone understands: Stay in character, Ask questions, Keep track of information, Talk to everyone!

Step 5: Keep the Game Flowing

As the host, your job is to keep the party moving and help if players get stuck. You can:

Drop hints if the investigation slows down-- have everyone reveal one piece of hide information to get the ball rolling!

Remind guests to mingle and share info. Our games are freeform style murder mystery games, which means guests act as detectives to solve the murder. Perfect for mixing different groups of friends or to create an interactive party that goes beyond a standard houseparty or dinner party.

Call everyone together for key moments--like reading the introduction or confession. 

Step 6: The Big Reveal

At the end, gather everyone to share their theories before announcing the murderer. You can have a prize for the best detective, best actor, or funniest performance to make it extra fun. The confession gives motivations fr all of the characters--the side plots are exciting!

Why First-Timers Love Guilty Games Murder Mysteries

Easy to follow – Clear instructions for both hosts and players, and the host can play along!

All-in-one kits – No extra planning stress and you can print from home!

Family-friendly options – Perfect for tweens, teens, and mixed-age groups

Unique themes – Something for every type of party

Quick Checklist for Your First Murder Mystery Party

✅ Murder mystery party game kit (print or digital)

✅ Character assignments

✅ Themed decorations

✅ Costumes or dress-up items

✅ Snacks and drinks

✅ Prize(s) for winners

✅ Music or playlist to set the mood

Final Word:
Planning your first murder mystery party doesn’t have to be overwhelming. With the right game, a great theme, and a little preparation, you can host an unforgettable night of laughter, intrigue, and drama.

If you’re ready to get started, check out Guilty Games Murder Mysteries for instant-download party kits that make hosting a breeze.

Back to blog